Nigerians and other African football lovers have erupted in anger following the release of the CAF Women’s Africa Cup of Nations (WAFCON) 2024 Best XI, slamming the omission of several standout performers, particularly “Super Falcons” defender Ashleigh Plumptre.
Plumptre, whose rock-solid defensive performances were instrumental in Nigeria clinching their record-extending 10th WAFCON title, was nowhere to be found in the team of the tournament, a move that fans have described as a “mockery” of merit.
Nigeria’s Dominance Overlooked
Despite Nigeria’s dominance at the tournament, only four players from the championship-winning squad, Rasheedat Ajibade (Best Player), Michelle Alozie, Chiamaka Nnadozie (Best Goalkeeper), and Esther Okoronkwo, made the final XI.
Fans and analysts alike questioned how Plumptre, Blessing Demehin, Osinachi Ohale, and even Christy Ucheibe, who were all pivotal to Nigeria’s minimal goals conceded and tactical organization, could be left out.
One fan wrote on X (formerly Twitter): “You can’t leave out Plumptre, who led that defense with calm and class. It’s an insult to the hard work of our women.” Another lamented: “Our backline was unbreakable, and only one made the XI? This isn’t recognition, it’s erasure!
Plumptre: The Symbol of Nigerian Resilience

Ashleigh Plumptre was not just a defender, she was a symbol of grit, leadership, and tactical discipline throughout the competition. Her emotional reaction after Nigeria’s triumph had gone viral, further endearing her to fans across Africa.
Supporters have called out CAF’s credibility, demanding transparency in how selections are made and asking if popularity or politics outweigh actual performance.
Fans Demand Accountability
Social media has been flooded with hashtags like “#JusticeForPlumptre” and “#WAFCONXIControversy”, as fans seek answers over the glaring snubs.
Critics argue that CAF’s selections fail to capture the true essence of the tournament’s standout moments and key contributors.
“This isn’t about favoritism,” a Nigerian supporter tweeted. “This is about recognizing players who bled for the badge and delivered.”
The backlash surrounding CAF’s WAFCON Best XI speaks volumes about the disconnect between official honours and on-field reality.
As fans continue to call for fairness and recognition of true performance, one thing is clear: the conversation about accountability in African women’s football has only just begun.